MOSCOW, November 22 (RIA Novosti) - The Kremlin on Thursday denied Russian media reports suggesting the period of mandatory military service for young men would be extended from a year to 18 months.
"No, that issue is not on the agenda today," said President Putin's press spokesman Dmitry Peskov. "There is an unequivocal position on this - to support one year [of service]" Peskov told Dozhd TV.
"This was Putin's decision and promise, and no-one intends to review that pledge," he added.
The Duma Defense Committee's Vladimir Komoyedov, a former Black Sea Fleet commander, told Izvestia cutting the draft to a year was "a political measure that had a bad effect on the army's preparedness."
He was also quoted as saying he would call on newly-appointed Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu to extend the draft period, in response to falling numbers of young men available for call up due to the country’s continuing demographic downward spiral.
Claiming that one year of military service is insufficient to train specialists, he added that the Duma Defense Committee would call for the draft service term to be reviewed.
The Defense Ministry denied any such plan is in the offing.
"The question of altering the military call-up term is not being considered at present," said the Defense Ministry's High Command Mobilization Directorate's head, Col. Vasily Smirnov.
Russia's High Command had earlier responded to Komoyedov's comments by saying it was "not against" an extension of the call-up period, which would allow better training of soldiers.
"If there was such a draft law put forward, I think we would not be against it being passed," High Command Mobilization Directorate spokeman Col. Alexei Knyazev said.
Human rights campaigners condemned the proposal, arguing it would be the end of military reform.
"I think this suggestion would sound the death-knell for military reform," said Sergei Krivenko, a member of the Presidential Human Rights Council and leader of the "Citizen and Army" pressure group. "A year and a half won't be enough – then it will be two or two and a half, and again this will lead to social tension. Then we'll have hazing, and all the old problems," he added.
The latest initiative is not the first effort by those opposed to military reform to turn the clock back, he noted.
"All these initiatives are part of the struggle to delay and hold back military reform," he said. The forces need to further develop the contract (professional) system in order to increase the term soldiers serve, he said.
Military service is mandatory for all Russian men from 18 to 27, although there are exemptions for those in higher education, those found medically unfit and those who are the fathers of two or more children. Draft-dodging is widespread, as army service remains extremely unpopular due to the lack of pay, poor service conditions, and widespread hazing, resulting in hundreds of non-combat deaths in the services every year.
Prosecutor General Yury Chaika reported in April 2011 that 478 soldiers died in Russia in 2010 in non-combat situations, down 14 percent on 2009.
Professional soldiers from other armies say the amount of time a conscript soldier serves is irrelevant - because his motivation is flawed from the start.
"You can train a person to become a soldier in six months," says "Dave," a former British Army Parachute Regiment soldier who asked his real name not be disclosed.
"You can give him tuition on weaponry, map-reading, living in the field, tactics etc. Most people can understand the basics after a six month period," he said. "What you cannot teach him is a good soldiering mindset. That comes from within."
Motivation is the critical factor, he stressed.
"If you want a purposeful army then you have to have volunteers – not call ups. "In a county the size of Russia they should expect to get a healthy number of volunteers, but the environment needs to change and a positive PR campaign needs to infiltrate the young man’s world from the age of 15 to 24. You capture this age range and offer something worthwhile then you have a fighting chance."
Add to blog
You may place this material on your blog by copying the link.
Image Galleries: Removing Protesters’ Barricades in Kiev
Infographics: First Russian Smartphone
Some people are trying to make the reality in Russia at least a bit more humane. The amnesty should apply not only to persons involved in high-profile cases, but also to individuals who are not as well-known. It is better to set free at least some of the individuals who deserve to be released than no one at all.