25/10/2014 13:29
RIA Novosti

Analysis & Opinion

The passion of the Roma à la russe

The passion of the Roma a la russe
23:44 16/09/2010

Romani culture, with all its controversial practices such as fortunetelling and horse theft, has been part of Russia's multicultural landscape for several centuries, and the attitude toward Roma people in this country has remained tolerant, if not friendly, from the beginning.

France's current deportations of Roma immigrants may be hailed as a sensible measure by Italy, Denmark, Belgium, Sweden, the Netherlands and other European nations that are about to follow suit, but to the Russians, this idea defies all logic.

The Russian Roma community now numbers 200,000 according to official estimates, while its members themselves put the population at half a million. And yet the community has never felt alien or pariah in this country, where Roma began to settle some 300 years ago. The first Romani groups came to Russia from Poland and were almost immediately granted Russian citizenship. Many of them converted into Orthodox Christianity, the country's dominant religion. A Senate decree of 1733 allowed Roma immigrants to reside here and engage in traditional occupations such as horse trading. Under this decree, they could join any estate, and in the 19th century Roma could be found among entertainers, merchants, bourgeoisie, and peasants.

In the 20th century, an era of sweeping changes in Russia, repeated attempts were made to acculturate Russian Roma, many of whom continued to maintain their traditional nomadic lifestyle. For instance, during the Bolsheviks' campaign to collectivize farming across Russia, traditional horse markets were outlawed, depriving Roma who traded in horses, stolen or otherwise, of their main source of income. The Soviet authorities also sought to make the Roma community settle in permanent residences. But many of its members chose to settle voluntarily after the Second World War. They took up farming and various crafts, blacksmithing being the most popular by far.

During WWII, Soviet Romani fought against the Nazis both as part of the regular army and guerrilla units. On occupied land, they were hunted down as targets of the Nazis' genocidal campaign. Many Roma in Russia survived thanks to sympathetic Russians who warned them of danger and offered them a place to hide.

On October 5, 1956, the Soviet parliament issued a decree intended to force all Roma "vagabonds" to give up their nomadic lifestyle and take mainstream jobs. This rather tough law was mitigated by certain economic incentives, such as free housing and land.

As for the Roma's cultural identity, it has never been infringed upon in this country. Moscow's Romen Theater, whose shows feature traditional Roma dances and songs, has garnered widespread popularity and acclaim with people of all ethnicities. Russian filmmakers have also helped promote Romani culture. Director Alexander Blank's 1979 television series "The Gypsy" ("Tsygan") with popular Soviet actors, and an earlier production by Emil Lotyanu, "A Gypsy Band Takes to the Skies" ("Tabor ukhodit v nebo") both enjoyed instant success with Soviet audiences.

Russia's interest in Romani art has a long history, predating the Soviet era. Many local aristocrats and members of the bourgeoisie had a strong passion for Gypsy songs and dances. Paradoxically, the lyrical chansons performed by Gypsies from Russia were widely regarded in Europe in the 20th century as an original Russian art form, and the emotional intensity of these songs was thought to be a manifestation of the deep Russian soul.

During Russia's trade boom of the 1990s, many Roma began travelling abroad for goods they could resell back home for a profit. Other traditional Romani occupations were revived during this time. Large families resorted to theft and swindling. Some also got involved in organized crime, including drug trafficking, contract killings, and fraudulent real estate schemes. In the criminal underworld, each tribal Romani group had its own speciality.

Fortunetelling, a traditional Romani occupation, became the most common livelihood for Russia's Roma people in the post-Soviet period. They also tried their hand at some new businesses, notably drug trafficking, and proved quite successful at it. According to St. Petersburg's anti-narcotics watchdog, it was Tajik people who took care of wholesale heroin supplies to Russia's second largest city, while Roman got involved in distribution, dealing drugs along with members of the Azerbaijani community. The Roma mafia, with its tradition of mutual responsibility, managed to build an extensive drug trafficking network, whose extreme secrecy made it difficult to detect.

Brazen acts, whether outlawed or legal, are quite typical of Russia's Roma people. Defiance, after all, is a major cultural trait of theirs. Naturally, many in Russia are surprised to see Roma in France now acquiesce to deportation. The cash compensation offered by the French authorities (300 euros for every adult and 100 euros for a child) may be part of the reason behind their orderly exodus, but it does not explain everything.

RIA Novosti commentator Olga Sobolevskaya

The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti.

  • Add to blog
  • Send to friend
  • Share

Add to blog

You may place this material on your blog by copying the link.

Publication code:


RIA NovostiThe passion of the Roma a la russeThe passion of the Roma à la russe

23:44 16/09/2010 Romani culture, with all its controversial practices such as fortunetelling and horse theft, has been part of Russia's multicultural landscape for several centuries, and the attitude toward Roma people in this country has remained tolerant, if not friendly, from the beginning.>>

Send by e-mail

All fields are required!

Leave a comment
  • pcfGreat Article
    01:05, 17/09/2010
    What a great article on the Roma in Russia. Thank you, Olga.
  • arnoldvinette@yahoo.comThank you Olga for information on the Roma Gypsies
    03:54, 17/09/2010
    After reading the article on France and the other countries that are trying to get rid of the Roma Gypsies I was immediately curious as to who they were.

    I live in North America and have never heard of the Roma Gypsies and so this was all very interesting.

    Thank you Olga for your insight into these very interesting people.

    I am happy to read that by and large the Russian people are very tolerant of their unique lifestyle and society which is predominantly nomadic.

    After reading it I wonder how their life style would fit into my new financial vision of "Work Credits" for countries to value all of their citizens as valuable natural resources upon which their money supply will be based.

    The Roma Gypsies appear to be very entrepreneurial and able to earn incomes to keep them well fed, clothed, educated and entertained.

    May other countries embrace the tolerance of the Roma Gypsies like Russia by accepting their nomadic lifestyle and finding a niche for them in their society.

    For the last 30 days I have been a North American gypsy as I traveled across the continent from San Francisco to Ottawa Canada. I have to admit it was fun being in a new place every few days. This life is not for everyone, but for those who choose it, room should be made to accommodate them where possible. That may be easier said than done though as I really do not understand how the Roma Gypsies move from place to place.

    Being from North America I have only ever known a static population. The only nomadic people we have per say are the truckers who move goods around the country. And this is not a nomadic population, but rather a working aspect of society.

    I would be interested in learning more about how a nomadic Roma society / clan works. How do they move? How do they live? Where do they live when they come to a new place? How do they benefit the community they arrive too? Why are they perceived as a problem when they move about? Obviously being nomadic Roma's carry few possessions with them and horses are valuable to move around.

    Arnold Vinette

© 2014  RIA Novosti
Some material may be inappropriate for those under 18